Broken link repair is the work of finding links that lead to an error page and either fixing the link or redirecting the old address to the right new one. This guide is for owners of local service businesses in the Twin Cities East Metro, the St. Croix Valley and western Wisconsin who searched for a Google broken link checker and want to know what to use and what to do with the results.
Google Webmaster Tools is now Google Search Console. In our experience Search Console has no tool by the name "broken link checker", but its Page indexing report lists pages Google could not index, including pages that returned a 404. It does not crawl your site the way a link checker does, so you need both.
Google Webmaster Tools is now Google Search Console
Google's announcement, dated May 20, 2015, says the company decided to rebrand Google Webmaster Tools as Google Search Console so the product would include everyone who cares about Search. Guides that still say Webmaster Tools describe the same free tool.
If you have not set it up yet, our guide to Google Search Console covers verification and the reports. This post uses one report from it and one kind of tool that Search Console is not.
What Search Console shows about broken links
Google's Page indexing report help page describes what the report lists. Three statuses matter for this task:
- Not found (404). The page returned a 404 error when Google requested it. The help page says Google might have found the URL as a link from another page, or the page may have existed before and been deleted. It also says 404 responses are not necessarily a problem if the page was removed without any replacement, and that if the page has moved you should use a 301 redirect to the new location.
- Soft 404. The page shows a friendly "not found" message but does not return a 404 status code. Google recommends returning a real 404 for pages that are truly not found.
- Page with redirect. A non-canonical URL that redirects to another page.
After you fix an issue, the help page says to open the issue's details and click Validate fix. It says validation typically takes up to about two weeks, and in some cases can take much longer.
In our reading, the report covers URLs Google has tried to fetch, so we would not expect it to list a dead link Google has not followed, or a broken link from your pages to another website.
How to find broken links Search Console does not list
A crawler fills that gap. A site crawler is a tool that starts at your home page, follows every link it can find and reports the ones that return an error. Both free and paid versions exist, and the category matters more than the product. What to ask of any crawler:
- Does it report internal links and outbound links separately?
- Does it show which page holds the broken link, so you know where to edit?
- Does it report redirects as well as errors, so you can see old links that still work only because of a redirect?
Run it after any change that moves pages: a redesign, a new service page structure, a switch of platform. Then run it on a schedule. Our post on website SEO maintenance places this check in a monthly routine.
What Google says about 404s and redirects
Google's page on HTTP status codes and network errors says that for 4xx status codes other than 429, Google does not index the URL, and a URL that was already indexed is removed from the index. It says newly encountered 404 pages are not processed. A soft 404 is described as a 2xx response whose content suggests an error, such as an empty page or an error message.
Google's page on redirects and Google Search says permanent redirects (301 and 308) tell Google the target should be the canonical page, and to use a permanent redirect when you are sure it will not be reverted. It says to use a permanent server-side redirect when a URL changes, and that server-side redirects are the most reliably interpreted method. Temporary redirects keep the source page in results.
Neither page says broken links lower rankings, and we are not making that claim. What the documentation supports is narrower. A URL that returns a 404 drops out of Google's index, and a visitor who follows a dead link reaches an error page. A redirect from the old address to the right new one lets both the visitor and Google find the replacement.
Broken link repair step by step
- Collect the list. Export the Not found (404) URLs from the Page indexing report and the broken links from your crawler.
- Sort by where the link lives. A link on your own pages is yours to edit. A link on another site needs a request or a redirect.
- Decide per URL. The page moved: add a 301 to the new address. The page was removed on purpose with no replacement: leave the 404, and remove links you control that point to it. The link was a typo: fix the link.
- Send each old address to its closest match. In our experience, redirecting every old URL to the home page is a poor match for the visitor, who lands somewhere unrelated to the link they clicked.
- Return a real 404 page for missing pages. A custom 404 page that returns a 404 status can offer your phone number and your main service links.
- Validate and re-crawl. Use Validate fix in Search Console and run the crawler again.
Scroll to see all columns
| Situation | What to do | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Page moved to a new address | 301 redirect to the new address | Google's help page says to use a 301 for a moved page |
| Page removed, no replacement | Leave a real 404 and remove your own links to it | Google's help page says 404s are not necessarily a problem here |
| Friendly error page returns a 200 status | Make it return a 404 status | Google recommends a 404 code for pages that are truly not found |
| Typo in one of your links | Correct the link | Our practice; no redirect needed |
| Broken outbound link | Replace it with a working source or remove it | Our practice |
| Chain of redirects | Point the first address at the final one | Our practice |
What a useful 404 page holds
A visitor who lands on a missing page is still a potential customer. A custom 404 page can say plainly that the page was not found, show your phone number, link to your main service pages and offer a search or contact link. For a business that takes calls from people with a leak or a no-heat problem, a phone number on the error page gives a visitor a quick way to reach you.
How to prioritize the list
A first crawl can return a long list. In our experience, start with links on pages people actually see: the home page, the service pages and the contact page. Next fix links that point to pages you have removed or renamed, since those are the ones a redirect solves in bulk. Leave low-traffic archive pages for last.
Where local businesses leave broken links behind
The places a service business leaves broken links are usually outside the website. These are our observations from this kind of work, not statistics.
- The Business Profile. Google's Edit your Business Profile page says you enter the full website URL, including https://, and lets some categories add links for things like appointments. A profile that still points to an old booking page or a page removed in a redesign sends the customer to an error.
- Local directories, chamber of commerce pages and sponsorship listings. A new site address or a renamed service page strands links that were set up years ago. Minnesota and Wisconsin chambers and event sponsor pages are easy to forget.
- Printed material. Door hangers, truck lettering, yard signs and QR codes carry an address that cannot be edited. Keep the old address redirecting for as long as the print is in circulation.
- Email signatures, estimates and invoice templates. These often hold a link to a page that no longer exists.
This is the main reason to keep a redirect list when you rebuild a site. Our website design work includes planning those redirects before launch, and the SEO, GEO and AEO service includes reviewing indexing and internal links.
If your site has changed addresses and you are not sure what still points to the old ones, contact McKinney Creative Ventures.