A marketing agency in the East Metro should be able to show you three things you can check yourself: an address that holds up if it claims a local office, local work you can look at, and a named person who will do your work. This guide is for owners of service businesses in Woodbury, Stillwater, Cottage Grove, Oakdale, Hudson and the rest of the St. Croix Valley who are comparing agencies and want to tell real local knowledge from a website that only says "local."
McKinney Creative Ventures is an agency in Woodbury, so we have a stake in the answer. The checks below work on any agency, including us. The general vetting questions, such as who runs your account, what gets reported and who owns the accounts, are in our guide to choosing a marketing agency. This post stays on the place.
What a marketing agency in the East Metro should know about this market
"East Metro" is an informal label, and people and agencies use it loosely. We use it for the area our service pages cover: Woodbury, Oakdale, Cottage Grove and Stillwater in Minnesota, and Hudson in Wisconsin, with the St. Croix Valley corridor out to River Falls, Wisconsin. Whatever label an agency uses, ask it to name the towns it means.
Three local facts shape the work. First, the customers sit in two states. Second, local search is measured from the searcher's position. Third, in our experience many service businesses here sell on a seasonal calendar. An agency that knows the market can explain how each one changes your plan.
On search, Google's page on improving your local ranking says local results are "mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity." It describes distance as how far each business is from the customer who is searching, and it says Google uses what it knows about a searcher's location when the searcher does not share one. In our reading, a business near the state line gets searches from both sides of it, so a useful agency looks at where your calls and form fills come from, because the address on your door is only part of the picture.
Six checks for a marketing agency in the East Metro
The table lists six checks you can run in an afternoon. None of them need the agency's permission, and most take a few minutes. The sections below expand four of them and add a quick read of the agency's own site.
Scroll to see all columns
| Check | How to run it | What a good answer looks like |
|---|---|---|
| The agency's own Business Profile | Search the agency's name on Google Maps and read the address, hours and reviews | A street address that is staffed during the listed hours |
| Local work | Ask for two or three live sites in your market, then search the service and the city yourself | Named businesses you can visit, and pages you can read without a login |
| Service-area setup | Ask how the agency would set your service area in your profile and on your site | A short list of towns that matches where your crews actually drive |
| The state line | Ask what changes between a Hudson customer and a Woodbury customer | A question about which state credentials you hold before any ad or page is written |
| Seasons | Ask what will be live before your busy season starts | A plan dated against your calendar, with a lead time |
| Who does the work | Ask who will log in to your accounts and who answers your email | A named person, with a stated backup |
Check the agency's own address
An agency that claims a local office should have one. Google's Business Profile guidelines say a rented mailing address where the business does not operate, which Google calls a virtual office, is not eligible for a profile. The same page says a business cannot list an office at a co-working space unless that office has clear signage, receives customers during business hours and is staffed during them. That is Google's rule for profiles, and it is a fair test for a "Stillwater office" on an agency's contact page. You can still hire a remote agency. You should know which one you are hiring.
Ask for local work you can verify
Ask to see live sites for businesses in your market, then run the search a customer would run. If a plumber near Cottage Grove ranks for "plumber Cottage Grove," open the page and read it as a customer would. Check that the phone number works, the service area is believable and the page says something a competitor could not copy. Be careful with results. Search positions move, and a screenshot from last spring proves little. A reference you can call tells you more, and our vetting guide covers how to run that call.
Ask who will do the work
Ask who will log in to your Business Profile, your website and your ad account, and ask to speak with that person before you sign. For this market, that person should be able to say which of your service towns is likely to bring the most calls without looking it up. Our vetting guide covers the rest of this check.
Read the agency's own site as a sample
An agency's website is the one piece of its work you can inspect without anyone's permission. Look at how its pages are written: whether they name the towns and trades it serves, whether the phone number and address match its Business Profile, and whether the pages load quickly on your phone. An agency that sells local search and keeps a thin, generic site of its own has told you something.
The state line changes what an agency needs to ask you
A Stillwater business and a Hudson business can answer to different state agencies. This section is general information, not legal advice, and your attorney or the state agency is the place to confirm what applies to your trade.
Minnesota's Department of Labor and Industry licenses residential building contractors, remodelers, roofers and manufactured home installers. Its residential contractor FAQ says license numbers must be on business cards, contracts, notices and statements relating to the filing of mechanics liens, and "all other advertising including websites." That FAQ applies to the licensees the department regulates and says nothing about other trades.
Wisconsin runs its own system. The Department of Safety and Professional Services describes a Dwelling Contractor credential that is held by a business and tied to building permits for one- and two-family dwellings. We have not compared the two states' advertising rules line by line, and an agency should not claim to have done it for you either. What a good agency does is ask which state credentials you hold before it writes the ad copy, the license line in your footer or the service pages for a customer across the state line.
Service areas and seasons in the St. Croix Valley
Google's help page on service-area businesses says you can set up to 20 service areas based on cities, postal codes or other areas you serve. The limit is generous, so the real work is choosing. A roofer in Woodbury and a landscaper in Hudson will not draw the same map, and neither should list every town the truck could reach on a good day. Ask the agency which towns it would include, which it would leave out, and what evidence it would use to decide, such as your past jobs by town.
Seasons work the same way. In our experience, many service businesses in Minnesota and western Wisconsin start preparing for a season after it has begun: snow removal and furnace work in the fall, roofing and lawn work in the spring. Ask the agency what it would have live four to six weeks before your busy months, and who approves it. Our Woodbury page and our marketing guide for Hudson, Wisconsin service businesses describe how we think about two of those markets, one on each side of the state line.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Which towns would you put in my service area, and which would you leave out?
- How would you treat searches that come from across the state line if my shop is in Minnesota, or the reverse?
- Which of my service towns do you expect to bring the most calls, and what would you check to confirm it?
- Which local businesses can I call, and what did you do for them?
- What will you ask me for in the first 30 days, such as logins, photos, a list of past jobs or a call with the person who answers the phone?
- Who owns the website, the Business Profile and the ad accounts if we part ways?
The last two questions come up in every agency decision and are covered in more detail in our vetting guide. For a market with a state line down the middle, the first two are the ones that separate an agency that knows the area from one that has only listed it.
Where McKinney Creative Ventures fits
McKinney Creative Ventures is based in Woodbury and works with businesses across the East Metro, the St. Croix Valley and western Wisconsin on websites, SEO, GEO and AEO, CRM and automation, digital advertising, and brand and copy. We do not claim an office outside Woodbury. If you want to see how we would treat your market, contact us and we will walk through it with you.