Seven small business website mistakes to check for are an unclear first screen, too many competing buttons, slow loading on a phone, proof that is missing or hard to verify, a vague service area, a contact path nobody has tested, and claims that have gone stale. This list is for owners of home service and trade businesses in the Twin Cities East Metro, the St. Croix Valley and western Wisconsin. Each mistake comes with a check you can run on your own site in a few minutes, and the fix.

This list gives no conversion-rate figures. Where we describe how visitors behave, we say it is our experience. Several of the seven are copy problems, and a later section says which.

Scroll to see all columns

MistakeQuick checkFixKind of problem
Unclear first screenShow a stranger your phone screen briefly and ask what you do and wherePut the work and the place in the headlineCopy
Competing buttonsCount everything tappable on the first phone screenKeep one primary action and move the rest downCopy and layout
Slow loading on a phoneRun the page in PageSpeed Insights and read the field data first when it appearsCompress images, remove heavy add-ons, review the hostBuild and hosting
Missing or unverifiable proofLook for a real review, a real photo and a credential after one scrollAdd genuine reviews with a link to where they live and photos of your own workContent
Vague service areaCompare your site's wording with your Business Profile service areasName the cities you serve on both sides of the St. CroixCopy
Untested contact pathCall the number and submit the form, then see who receives eachFix the routing, add a confirmation, name an ownerSetup and process
Stale or unverifiable claimsRead every hour, license number and photo as a stranger wouldUpdate it, date it or remove itCopy and facts

Small business website mistakes on the first screen

Mistake 1: Nobody can tell what you do and where

In our experience, a visitor decides quickly whether this is the right company. A headline such as "Quality you can trust" answers neither question the visitor is asking: what you do, and whether you work where they live.

Check: open the site on your phone, hand it to someone outside your business and take it back after a few seconds. Our five second website test covers the method. Fix: write the headline in the customer's words and include the place, such as "Roof repair and replacement in Woodbury and the East Metro".

Mistake 2: Too many competing buttons

A first screen with "Call Us", "Email Us", "Learn More" and "Follow Us" gives a visitor four equal choices, and only one or two of them lead to a booked job. We have no study to cite on how many buttons is too many. Our judgment is that a homeowner with water in the basement should not have to choose among four options to reach you.

Check: screenshot the first phone screen and count everything a thumb can tap, including the menu, phone numbers, buttons and social icons. Fix: pick the action that starts a job, usually a call or a short request form, and make it the only filled button. Turn the others into plain text links, and move social icons to the footer.

Mistake 3: Slow loading on a phone

web.dev's Web Vitals guide (last updated October 31, 2024) lists good targets of 2.5 seconds for Largest Contentful Paint, 200 milliseconds or less for Interaction to Next Paint and 0.1 or less for Cumulative Layout Shift, measured at the 75th percentile of page loads, segmented across mobile and desktop devices.

The guide adds that lab measurement is not a substitute for field measurement. Check: enter your home page and your main service page in PageSpeed Insights. Its documentation says the real-user data comes from the Chrome User Experience Report and covers the previous 28-day collection period, and that a page or origin passes the Core Web Vitals assessment, when there is enough data, if the 75th percentiles of all three metrics are Good. Google also says a page can have too few real-user samples, in which case PageSpeed Insights falls back to data for the whole site or shows none. Read the field data first when it appears, because Google says lab data is collected in a controlled environment and may not capture real-world bottlenecks.

Fix: in our experience, the usual causes are oversized photos, scripts added by plugins and widgets, and a slow host. Compress images first, remove add-ons nobody uses, and ask your host or builder what is serving the page. This is the one mistake on the list that editing words will not fix. Tap target size and accessibility are in our modern website design guide, and hosting is part of our website design service.

Mistake 4: Proof that is missing or cannot be checked

BrightLocal's Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 (published February 2026, 1,002 US adult consumers) reports that after reading positive reviews, 54% of consumers then visit the business's website. The percentages it gives for what people do next add up to more than 100%, which in our reading means respondents could choose more than one. It is a national sample, not an East Metro one. In our experience, a visitor may arrive having read your reviews already and uses the site to check you.

Check: load the home page on a phone, scroll once, and look for a review quote or rating linked to where it lives, a photo of your own crew, truck or finished work, and a credential a visitor could verify. Fix: put the strongest genuine review near the first action, link it to where the full review lives, and replace stock photos with your own.

Keep the proof real. The FTC's rule at 16 CFR 465.2 says it is an unfair or deceptive practice and a violation for a business to write, create or sell a consumer review or testimonial that materially misrepresents that the reviewer exists, used the business, or had the experience described. Never use a tool to write a review that pretends to come from a customer. This is general information and not legal advice, so ask your attorney how it applies.

Local mistakes: service area, contact path and stale claims

Mistake 5: A service area that is missing, vague or one-sided

"Serving the Twin Cities and surrounding areas" does not tell a homeowner in Hudson, Wisconsin, whether a Woodbury company drives across the river, or a Stillwater homeowner whether you work in the St. Croix Valley. Minnesota and Wisconsin have different permits and licensing, so say plainly which side or sides you work on.

Google's service areas help page says a Business Profile service area is set by city, postal code or other area, with up to 20 areas and no radius. That page covers the profile and says nothing about your website, so matching the two is our recommendation.

Check: put your site next to your profile's service areas. Does the site name those places, and would you drive to each one for a standard job? Fix: write the list in plain words on the contact page and each service page, such as "We serve Woodbury, Oakdale, Stillwater and Hudson, Wisconsin", and remove any place you do not really serve.

Mistake 6: A contact path nobody has tested

Here is an illustrative example with an invented company. Pennyroyal Roofing, a made-up Woodbury roofer, changed office managers last spring. Its request form still emails the old address, and the phone number on the page is plain text, so a visitor on a phone has to copy it. The owner sees no error, because the site looks fine.

Check: do all of these yourself, on a phone, from your own site.

  • Tap the phone number and confirm it opens the dialer, then let it ring through to see who answers, including after hours.
  • Submit the request form with your own name and the word "test", and note who receives it, at which address and how quickly. Check spam too.
  • Read what the person submitting sees afterward. A confirmation that says when to expect a reply helps, as long as you can keep that promise.

Fix: send entries to an address or CRM that a named person watches, and repeat this test after any change of staff, phone number or form tool. If the test passes and leads still do not come, our guide to website traffic with no leads traces where visitors drop off.

Mistake 7: Stale or unverifiable claims

Hours, credentials, photos and testimonials go stale or draw doubt.

Hours. Google's help page on how to set special hours says you can schedule special business hours for holidays, special events and other exceptional circumstances. It does not address the hours shown on your website, so the link is our advice: when the profile says closed for a holiday, the site's footer and contact page should say the same. Remove any "24/7" line your staffing cannot honor.

License numbers. Minnesota's rule is Minn. Stat. 326B.87, subdivision 2: the license number of a licensee must appear in any advertising by that licensee, and the statute's examples include websites. The definition in section 326B.802 lists a residential building contractor, residential remodeler, manufactured home installer and residential roofer as licensees, so a business in another trade should ask the Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry what its own license requires. For a Wisconsin contractor, the DSPS Dwelling Contractor page is about the credential and its application, and it has no passage on advertising, so ask DSPS or your attorney what applies to your trade. This is general information and not legal advice.

Photos and testimonials. A stock photo of a smiling crew presented as your crew is a claim about who will show up at the door. Your own photos hold up better, because the technician who arrives cannot contradict them. For testimonials, see the FTC rule under Mistake 4.

Check: read every hour, license number, photo and testimonial and ask whether you could prove it today. Fix: update it, add a date where one belongs, or remove it.

Which of the seven are copy problems

In our reading, mistakes 1, 2, 5 and 7 are mostly copy problems, mistake 4 is a content problem, and mistake 6 is a setup problem. Only mistake 3 usually needs work on the build or the host.

Run the other checks before you decide the site needs a rebuild, because they cost the least. If the speed check still fails after you fix the images and remove unused add-ons, or the site cannot be edited without a developer, the structure is the problem and a rebuild becomes a reasonable conversation.

What to fix first

Our order is the contact path, then the first screen, then proof, then the service area and claims, then speed. A lead that arrives and goes nowhere wastes whatever you spent to bring the visitor, so the test in mistake 6 comes first.

For a second set of eyes on your list, our website work covers design, rebuilds, hosting, ongoing management and custom web apps, and you can contact us to talk it through.